DIY Halloween Decorations on a Budget

Every October I promise myself I am going to be normal about Halloween decor. And every October I end up sitting on the kitchen floor at ten at night with a hot glue gun, cheesecloth stuck to my leggings, and a very concerned husband asking if I want water.

This year I am pregnant and moving a lot slower, so I had to actually get strategic instead of just buying things and hoping. Weirdly, it made everything look better. Here is the thing nobody says out loud. The expensive Halloween stuff usually looks worse in a real house than the cheap stuff does. Store lighting is doing a lot of heavy lifting. Meanwhile four dollar store pumpkins and one good candle can carry an entire entryway.

Heads up, some of these are affiliate links, which just means I get a tiny commission at no cost to you.

Cheesecloth Ghosts, The One Craft Worth The Mess

These are the only DIY Halloween decoration I make every single year, because they cost almost nothing and they genuinely look expensive. You need cheesecloth, about four dollars a package at the grocery store in the baking aisle near the twine, a bottle of liquid starch or a cup of watered down school glue, and something to drape over.

The shape is the whole trick. I use a balloon on top of an empty wine bottle for a tall ghost, and a styrofoam ball on a paper towel tube for a smaller one. Dunk the cheesecloth, squeeze it out so it is damp and not dripping, drape it, and then fuss with the folds for about thirty seconds. Let it dry overnight. It will be stiff enough to hold its shape in the morning.

What I learned the hard way. Do not use fabric stiffener spray. It never fully sets and my ghost slowly collapsed over three days like it was giving up on life. Liquid starch, the actual laundry kind, works every time. One package of cheesecloth makes three ghosts, so you are looking at maybe six dollars total for a whole little haunted shelf.

The Dollar Store Pumpkin Glow Up

Foam pumpkins from the dollar store look exactly like foam pumpkins from the dollar store. Orange, shiny, slightly sad. But two coats of cheap matte black or off white craft paint completely changes them, and craft paint is under a dollar a bottle.

Paint them, and then while the second coat is still tacky, dust the stems and the ridges with a little cinnamon or cocoa powder from your pantry. It sounds unhinged. It gives them this dusty, aged, ceramic look that people always ask about. It lasts the season fine as long as they are not sitting somewhere humid.

Six pumpkins, two bottles of paint, roughly eight dollars, and they read as the expensive velvet ones from across the room.

Paper Bats, But Please Not The Flat Ones

Everyone does the black paper bats up the wall. The reason most of them look like a third grade art project is that they are flat and evenly spaced. Fix both things. Fold the wings up slightly along the body so they cast a shadow, and cluster them tight at the bottom of the wall with a few stragglers drifting up and out. Uneven is the point.

Use black cardstock, not construction paper, which goes gray and floppy within a week. A pack of cardstock is about five dollars and makes way more bats than you need. Attach them with the small clear removable adhesive dots so you are not patching drywall in November. I learned that one personally.

Grocery Store Flowers, Halloween Edition

This is my favorite cheap trick. Get the ugliest, cheapest bunch of grocery store flowers you can find, usually the eight dollar mixed bouquet nobody wants. Pull out anything colorful. Keep the eucalyptus, the seeded pods, the weird brown filler, all the dried looking stuff. Then add a few branches from your own yard.

Stick all of it in a dark vase or an old bottle. It looks moody and intentional and costs less than a single stem of the fake stuff. In Kansas City the yard branches are gorgeous by mid October anyway, so half of it is free.

The Front Porch For About Twenty Dollars

Porch decor is where people blow the budget, and it is genuinely the easiest place to fake it. My whole porch is three real pumpkins from the grocery store, two thrifted lanterns with battery candles inside, and a bundle of corn stalks zip tied to the railing.

Real pumpkins are usually cheaper than the fake ones and they look infinitely better. Buy them the week of Halloween, not in September, because the ones you buy early will be soft and leaking by the thirty first. Ask me how I know.

Battery tea lights are the single best five dollars in Halloween. Put them in everything. Mason jars, old wine bottles, the lanterns, inside a carved pumpkin so you are not lighting an actual flame next to a pile of dry corn stalks.

My Actual Supply List

• Cheesecloth, one package, about four dollars, makes three ghosts
• Liquid starch, about four dollars, and it lasts several years
• Black cardstock, one pack, about five dollars
• Matte craft paint in black and off white, about two dollars total
• Six foam dollar store pumpkins, six dollars
• Battery tea lights, twelve pack, about five dollars
• Clear removable adhesive dots, about four dollars
• Three real pumpkins, about twelve dollars depending on size
• One sad grocery store bouquet, about eight dollars

That is right around fifty dollars for a whole house, and the starch, paint, and tea lights carry over to next year. Realistically year two costs me under twenty five.

What I Would Skip

Fake spider web. I know, it is a classic. But it looks cheap on day one, it collects actual dust within a week, and it is a nightmare to get off of bushes and railings. I have picked synthetic web out of a boxwood in January. Never again.

Also the inflatable yard stuff, and not because it is tacky. I actually love a big goofy inflatable. It is because the cheap ones fail. The fans die, they slump over by seven in the morning, and you cannot really repair them. If you want one, that is the place to spend real money or skip it entirely.

And candles labeled pumpkin something. Nine times out of ten they smell like a car air freshener. A plain black or unscented pillar candle plus something actually simmering on the stove, orange peel, a cinnamon stick, a couple cloves, does more for the vibe and costs pocket change.

The Short Version

Cheap Halloween decor works when you lean into texture and shadow instead of trying to buy something that looks expensive. Cheesecloth, matte paint, real pumpkins, and a lot of little flickering lights. That is basically the whole formula, and it holds up year after year.

If you make the ghosts, please do the wine bottle trick. It is a game changer and it makes the wine feel productive.

So glad you are here. Pam